| Children |
| | 1. Horton, Caleb, b. 1673, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 1673, Long Island City, Queens, New York, United States (Age 0 years) |
| | 2. Horton, Bethia, b. 1674, Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America d. 14 Mar 1744, Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 70 years) |
| | 3. Horton, Mehitable, b. 16 Feb 1679, Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America d. 9 Sep 1757, Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America (Age 78 years) |
| | 4. Horton, Abigail, b. 1681, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 19 May 1769, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 88 years) |
| | 5. Horton, Jonathan Jr, b. 23 Dec 1683, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 2 Apr 1768, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 84 years) |
| | 6. Horton, Caleb, b. 23 Dec 1687, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 6 Aug 1772, Chester, Orange, New York, United States (Age 84 years) |
| | 7. Horton, Patience, b. 1692, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 14 Apr 1729, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 37 years) |
| | 8. Horton, Deacon James, b. 1694, Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America d. 16 May 1762, Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America (Age 68 years) |
|